Ambrose Evans-Pritchard, the Telegraph's international business editor, has followed the global financial crisis from the credit crunch to the eurozone debt crisis. Here is a selection of news and views from his stories, blogs and columns over the past five years. 9 August, 2007: Dow crashes 387 as contagion spreads after the European Central Bank provides emergency liquidity to the credit markets for the first time since the 9/11 terrorist attacks, acting to prevent contagion from the US sub-prime mortgage slump spreading through the German, French, and Dutch banking systems.
Anybody who has been on holiday has come back to face a different world.
It's the Wild West right now," said David Bloom, chief currency
strategist at HSBC. "Investors can't decide whether we're looking at a
fundamental crisis."
22 December, 2007: Crisis
may make 1929 look a 'walk in the park'
The kind of upheaval observed in the international money markets over the
past few months has never been witnessed in history," says Thomas
Jordan, a Swiss central bank governor. "The sub-prime mortgage crisis
hit a vital nerve of the international financial system."Ambrose: The risk for Britain – as property buckles – is a twin banking and fiscal squeeze. The UK budget deficit is already 3 per cent of GDP at the peak of the economic cycle, shockingly out of line with its peers.
Maastricht rules may force the Government to raise taxes or slash spending into a recession. This way lies crucifixion. The UK current account deficit was 5.7 per cent of GDP in the second quarter, the highest in half a century. Gordon Brown has disarmed us on every front.
------
Ambrose:
The ECB's little secret is that it must never allow a Northern Rock failure
in the eurozone because this would expose the reality that there is no EU
treasury and no EU lender of last resort behind the system. Would German
taxpayers foot the bill for a Spanish bail-out in the way that Kentish men
and maids must foot the bill for Newcastle's Rock? Nobody knows. This is
where eurozone solidarity stretches to snapping point. It is why the ECB has
showered the system with liquidity from day one of this crisis.
20 January: Euro at risk from Europe's economic storm
If the storm is peaking in the US, it has hardly begun in Europe. Bernard
Connolly, global strategist at Banque AIG, says euro-losses may surpass the
US debacle.
The next really big shock to financial markets is likely to be the risk of collapse in the EMU credit bubble: the private sector credit consequences are likely to be catastrophic," he said.
Ambrose comment: We are nearing the moment when the ECB must decide whether it is a bank or the political guardian of the EU Project. It cannot be both.
Spanish banks are issuing mortgage bonds to use as collateral at the ECB's window, without even trying to sell them on the open market ... Whatever happens, it is already too late to avoid the Latin Crisis of 2008.
18 March: Sooner Fed bail-outs than the 1930s revisited
Any smug assumption that this will remain a local American affair may soon
be confounded. The IMF has abruptly changed its tune. "Obviously the
financial market crisis is now more serious and more global than a week ago,"
it said on Monday.
Property booms will soon be deflating across the Anglo-Saxon world and the eurozone's Club Med belt. Japan is already on the brink of recession. Debt levels are higher now in most rich countries than they were in 1929. The levels of financial leverage are greater.
As the Bank for International Settlements wrote last year, we are more vulnerable to a 1930s dénouement than people realise – should the authorities botch the response.
15 September: Who's next after Lehman Brothers is fed to the wolves?
Superficially, one can blame Lehman and its ilk for the excesses that led
to this crisis. However, the root cause lies in the actions of governments
across the Western world. They held interest rates too low for much of the
past two decades, and encouraged the debt burden to explode to unprecedented
levels.
This reckless experiment has left our societies acutely vulnerable to a sudden reversal of debt issuance, or ''deleveraging" as it is known. The ferocious purge now under way will come at a high human cost. Millions in Britain, Europe, the US, and the rest of the world will lose their jobs over the next two years, through no fault of their own.
Having caused this crisis, it would now be remiss for governments to pursue a policy of strict debt liquidation in the name of capitalist purity.
20 December: Protectionist dominoes are beginning to tumble across the world
This crisis has already brought us a monetary revolution as interest rates
approach zero across the G10. It may overturn the "New World Order"
as well, unless we move with great care in grim months ahead. This is where
events turn dangerous.
The last great era of globalisation peaked just before 1914. You know the rest of the story.
A great ring of EU states stretching from Eastern Europe down across Mare
Nostrum to the Celtic fringe are either in a 1930s depression already or
soon will be. Greece's social fabric is unravelling before the pain begins,
which bodes ill.
Each is a victim of ill-judged economic policies foisted upon them by elites in thrall to Europe's monetary project – either in EMU or preparing to join – and each is trapped.
24 September: Spain tips into depression
For the time being, an odd calm prevails across the Iberian peninsular.
There are no street riots, even though youth unemployment has reached 38pc.
It is hard to imagine anything like the bloody uprising by Asturian miners
in 1934, the last time so many people were without jobs.
---
Spain no longer has the escape valve of devaluation to claw back market share. It cannot resort to emergency monetary stimulus – as Switzerland, Britain, the US, and Japan are doing.
---
Membership of the EU and the euro is inextracably linked in Spain's collective mind to the country's re-emergence as a modern, dynamic European power after the stultifying isolation of the Franco dictatorship. It would take a major trauma to test that bond.
13 December: Greece defies Europe as EMU crisis turns deadly serious
While the ECB may not bail out states, it may buy Greek bonds in the open
market. EU states may club together to keep Greece afloat with loans for a
while. That solves nothing. It increases Greece's debt, drawing out the
agony. What Greece needs – unless it leaves EMU – is a permanent subsidy
from the North. Spain and Portugal will need help too.
EMU architects were warned in the early 1990s that monetary union would
prove unworkable as constructed. They scoffed, sure that any crisis could be
exploited to force the pace of economic union. Commission chief Romano Prodi
later admitted as much. "The euro will oblige us to introduce a new set
of economic policy instruments. It is politically impossible now. But some
day there will be a crisis and new instruments will be created."
We will soon learn if this gamble will pay off, or prove catastrophically wrong.
4 July: With the US trapped in depression, this really is starting to feel like 1932
It is obvious what that policy should be for Europe, America, and Japan.
If budgets are to shrink in an orderly fashion over several years – as they
must, to avoid sovereign debt spirals – then central banks will have to
cushion the blow keeping monetary policy ultra-loose for as long it takes.
29 November: Germany faces its awful choice as Spain wobbles
It is clear to those working in the bond markets that the debt crisis in
the EMU periphery is nearing danger point, and risks spiralling out of
control as quickly as the Lehman-AIG-Fannie-Freddie crisis in 2008.
Prof Willem Buiter, chief economist at Citigroup, said last week that Portugal is likely to need a rescue before the end of the year and that Spain will follow “soon after”.
This 'Fusion or Fission’ debate has not been settled. Yes, there has been
much talk about Eurobonds and rescues. Talk is cheap. The reality of
Germany's 'rescue policy' is to extract subsidy from the periphery by
lending to Greece and Ireland at rates far above its own borrowing cost,
widening the gap between core and periphery yet further.
14 July: Return of the Gold Standard as world order unravels
Step by step, the world is edging towards a revived Gold Standard as it
becomes clearer that Japan and the West have reached debt saturation. World
Bank chief Robert Zoellick said it was time to "consider employing gold
as an international reference point." The Swiss parliament is to hold
hearings on a parallel "Gold Franc". Utah has recognised gold as
legal tender for tax payments.
6 November: Europe's rescue fiasco leaves Italy defenceless
Italy’s travails have little to do with the parallel drama in Greece. This
is not contagion in any meaningful sense. The country is suddenly under fire
for the very simple reason that its economy is plunging back into deep
recession, the predicable outcome of the EU’s 1930s fiscal and monetary
contraction policies.
If pessimists are right, it will become clear within months that Greece
needs an even bigger rescue package, this time with "haircuts" for
the EU's creditor states as well. Any such request is likely to stretch
patience in the German, Dutch and Finnish parliaments to snapping point.
3 June: The week that Europe stopped pretending
The euro has essentially broken down as a viable economic and political
undertaking. The latest rush of events reeks of impending denouement.
2 August Draghi delivers
Wow, the ECB really is preparing to hit the nuclear button. Mario Draghi has activated the ECB's monetary policy, risk, and market committees to draw up drastic plans.
This will include open-market operations – ie bond purchases – that may be "unlimited" and may be "unsterilised" (ie QE net stimulus).
The missile is being loaded. The launch trigger is being cocked (if you cock such things).
Markets have tanked because they don’t get instant gratification, but I rather suspect that they have missed the point.
20 January: Euro at risk from Europe's economic storm
If the storm is peaking in the US, it has hardly begun in Europe. Bernard
Connolly, global strategist at Banque AIG, says euro-losses may surpass the
US debacle.
The next really big shock to financial markets is likely to be the risk of collapse in the EMU credit bubble: the private sector credit consequences are likely to be catastrophic," he said.
Ambrose comment: We are nearing the moment when the ECB must decide whether it is a bank or the political guardian of the EU Project. It cannot be both.
Spanish banks are issuing mortgage bonds to use as collateral at the ECB's window, without even trying to sell them on the open market ... Whatever happens, it is already too late to avoid the Latin Crisis of 2008.
18 March: Sooner Fed bail-outs than the 1930s revisited
Any smug assumption that this will remain a local American affair may soon
be confounded. The IMF has abruptly changed its tune. "Obviously the
financial market crisis is now more serious and more global than a week ago,"
it said on Monday.
Property booms will soon be deflating across the Anglo-Saxon world and the eurozone's Club Med belt. Japan is already on the brink of recession. Debt levels are higher now in most rich countries than they were in 1929. The levels of financial leverage are greater.
As the Bank for International Settlements wrote last year, we are more vulnerable to a 1930s dénouement than people realise – should the authorities botch the response.
15 September: Who's next after Lehman Brothers is fed to the wolves?
Superficially, one can blame Lehman and its ilk for the excesses that led
to this crisis. However, the root cause lies in the actions of governments
across the Western world. They held interest rates too low for much of the
past two decades, and encouraged the debt burden to explode to unprecedented
levels.
This reckless experiment has left our societies acutely vulnerable to a sudden reversal of debt issuance, or ''deleveraging" as it is known. The ferocious purge now under way will come at a high human cost. Millions in Britain, Europe, the US, and the rest of the world will lose their jobs over the next two years, through no fault of their own.
Having caused this crisis, it would now be remiss for governments to pursue a policy of strict debt liquidation in the name of capitalist purity.
20 December: Protectionist dominoes are beginning to tumble across the world
This crisis has already brought us a monetary revolution as interest rates
approach zero across the G10. It may overturn the "New World Order"
as well, unless we move with great care in grim months ahead. This is where
events turn dangerous.
The last great era of globalisation peaked just before 1914. You know the rest of the story.
2009
17 January: Monetary union has left half of Europe trapped in depression
A great ring of EU states stretching from Eastern Europe down across Mare
Nostrum to the Celtic fringe are either in a 1930s depression already or
soon will be. Greece's social fabric is unravelling before the pain begins,
which bodes ill.
Each is a victim of ill-judged economic policies foisted upon them by elites in thrall to Europe's monetary project – either in EMU or preparing to join – and each is trapped.
24 September: Spain tips into depression
For the time being, an odd calm prevails across the Iberian peninsular.
There are no street riots, even though youth unemployment has reached 38pc.
It is hard to imagine anything like the bloody uprising by Asturian miners
in 1934, the last time so many people were without jobs.
---
Spain no longer has the escape valve of devaluation to claw back market share. It cannot resort to emergency monetary stimulus – as Switzerland, Britain, the US, and Japan are doing.
---
Membership of the EU and the euro is inextracably linked in Spain's collective mind to the country's re-emergence as a modern, dynamic European power after the stultifying isolation of the Franco dictatorship. It would take a major trauma to test that bond.
13 December: Greece defies Europe as EMU crisis turns deadly serious
While the ECB may not bail out states, it may buy Greek bonds in the open
market. EU states may club together to keep Greece afloat with loans for a
while. That solves nothing. It increases Greece's debt, drawing out the
agony. What Greece needs – unless it leaves EMU – is a permanent subsidy
from the North. Spain and Portugal will need help too.
2010
31 January: Should Germany bail out Club Med or leave the euro altogether?
EMU architects were warned in the early 1990s that monetary union would
prove unworkable as constructed. They scoffed, sure that any crisis could be
exploited to force the pace of economic union. Commission chief Romano Prodi
later admitted as much. "The euro will oblige us to introduce a new set
of economic policy instruments. It is politically impossible now. But some
day there will be a crisis and new instruments will be created."
We will soon learn if this gamble will pay off, or prove catastrophically wrong.
4 July: With the US trapped in depression, this really is starting to feel like 1932
It is obvious what that policy should be for Europe, America, and Japan.
If budgets are to shrink in an orderly fashion over several years – as they
must, to avoid sovereign debt spirals – then central banks will have to
cushion the blow keeping monetary policy ultra-loose for as long it takes.
29 November: Germany faces its awful choice as Spain wobbles
It is clear to those working in the bond markets that the debt crisis in
the EMU periphery is nearing danger point, and risks spiralling out of
control as quickly as the Lehman-AIG-Fannie-Freddie crisis in 2008.
Prof Willem Buiter, chief economist at Citigroup, said last week that Portugal is likely to need a rescue before the end of the year and that Spain will follow “soon after”.
2011
20 February: Germany must choose EMU fusion or fission
This 'Fusion or Fission’ debate has not been settled. Yes, there has been
much talk about Eurobonds and rescues. Talk is cheap. The reality of
Germany's 'rescue policy' is to extract subsidy from the periphery by
lending to Greece and Ireland at rates far above its own borrowing cost,
widening the gap between core and periphery yet further.
14 July: Return of the Gold Standard as world order unravels
Step by step, the world is edging towards a revived Gold Standard as it
becomes clearer that Japan and the West have reached debt saturation. World
Bank chief Robert Zoellick said it was time to "consider employing gold
as an international reference point." The Swiss parliament is to hold
hearings on a parallel "Gold Franc". Utah has recognised gold as
legal tender for tax payments.
6 November: Europe's rescue fiasco leaves Italy defenceless
Italy’s travails have little to do with the parallel drama in Greece. This
is not contagion in any meaningful sense. The country is suddenly under fire
for the very simple reason that its economy is plunging back into deep
recession, the predicable outcome of the EU’s 1930s fiscal and monetary
contraction policies.
2012
21 February: Greek debt accord hostage to political passions
If pessimists are right, it will become clear within months that Greece
needs an even bigger rescue package, this time with "haircuts" for
the EU's creditor states as well. Any such request is likely to stretch
patience in the German, Dutch and Finnish parliaments to snapping point.
3 June: The week that Europe stopped pretending
The euro has essentially broken down as a viable economic and political
undertaking. The latest rush of events reeks of impending denouement.
2 August Draghi delivers
Wow, the ECB really is preparing to hit the nuclear button. Mario Draghi has activated the ECB's monetary policy, risk, and market committees to draw up drastic plans.
This will include open-market operations – ie bond purchases – that may be "unlimited" and may be "unsterilised" (ie QE net stimulus).
The missile is being loaded. The launch trigger is being cocked (if you cock such things).
Markets have tanked because they don’t get instant gratification, but I rather suspect that they have missed the point.
No comments:
Post a Comment