By
Keiligh Baker: A man was charged with rape despite the woman involved in the case telling police that he had not committed a crime.
The
man, known as Male Two, visited the woman's home with another man, Male
One, and the three ended up in bed together - but the woman soon
believed she was being taken advantage of.
When
she shouted 'stop' Male Two stopped but Male One continued to have sex
with her against her will. The woman said Male Two then pulled the other
man away, a fact she told police, making it clear Male One had raped
her but Male Two had not.
The Times reports that police charged the man with rape even though the woman insisted that he had committed no crime.
She
told police: 'I do not believe Male Two should be charged. I do not
believe he did anything wrong on the night. I am thankful that Male Two
was there as without him I do not know how long Male One would have
continued to have sex with me.'
The CPS
had her statement but still charged both men with rape and took the
case to court in January. Male Two's barrister was only made aware of
the woman's statement on the first day of his rape trial.
A judge told the prosecution to review the decision to bring the case to court and it dropped the case against Male Two.
But
the woman also withdrew her support for the prosecution of the man she
says raped her because she no longer trusted the system.
The case was brought to light by an episode of the BBC’s Panorama programme which will air tonight.
The
Crown Prosecution Service has been left reeling following a series of
collapsed rape trials in recent months. The Director of Public
Prosecutions, Alison Saunders, also oversaw controversial - and failed -
prosecutions of journalists and historic child abuse cases. She will
stand down in October after five years in the role.
Mrs
Saunders denied claims the CPS has failed under her watch, insisting
her prosecutors were performing as well or better than ever before in
courts up and down the country despite budget cuts.
And
she insisted measures were taken to address concerns about evidence
disclosure in rape cases following a series of high-profile trials
collapsed last year.
Mrs Saunders, who earned £250,000 as DPP in 2017, started her career at the CPS in 1986.
The
high-flying lawyer has come under fire for insisting no innocent person
is in jail after being wrongly convicted because of mistakes in
disclosure. Data obtained by the BBC under the Freedom of Information
Act found the number of prosecutions that have collapsed because of
blunders in disclosing crucial evidence has soared by 70 per cent in the
past two years.
More than 900 suspects had charges dropped last year because police and prosecutors failed to hand evidence to defence lawyers.
In
the lead up to criminal trials, police and prosecutors have a duty to
disclose evidence that might either assist the defence case or undermine
the prosecution.
But the recent
collapse of several rape cases has heightened concerns that evidence is
not being disclosed early enough, and that the rules are not being
followed.
No comments:
Post a Comment