'The Glasgow story is a cautionary tale for those who hope that public
institutions will respond to politically motivated complaints of
anti-Semitism by relying on evidence and following standard procedures.'
Image: Nick Fells at work (left). Bryony Randall (right). The pair led censorship efforts at Glasgow university. By David Miller: A Scottish university refused to properly assess pro-Israel complaints about a peer-reviewed article in one of its journals.
Instead of sending the complaints to the author of the paper for
further peer review, the university asked a staff member “close to the
[subject] area” to give an informal view.
University documents released under freedom of information rules show
it was agreed that the paper – which discussed the Israel lobby in
Britain – should also be sent for external review, but this seems not to
have been done.
But even this was only agreed after the university had already
decided on its response – to endorse the baseless smears of the
complainants.